The Pros and Cons of Different Pet Training Methods

As a pet owner, you want to ensure your furry friend receives the best possible training to lead a happy and healthy life. Training can be accomplished in several ways, each with its own benefits and drawbacks.

What’s more, when you’re dealing with, say, your golden retriever, you’re not just training a pet – you’re shaping a lifelong companion who will be by your side through thick and thin. Therefore, it’s essential to understand the pros and cons of different pet training methods before deciding which one to use. This is why you should also be aware of golden retriever health issues, to ensure your companion receives the best care possible.

Positive Reinforcement Training

Positive reinforcement training is the superstar of pet training methods! It’s the go-to choice for professional trainers and pet owners alike. Why? Because it’s all about treats, praise, and rewards for our furry friends when they nail it!


  • Reinforces good behavior, making pet-owner communication top-notch.
  • Builds an unbreakable bond and cultivates awesome habits over time.
  • Boosts your pet’s trust, confidence, and self-esteem. They’ll strut their stuff like a pro!


  • Patience and persistence are key. Instant results? Not always.
  • Sometimes, certain breeds or challenging behavior traits may need an extra positive touch.
  • But hey, watch out for too many treats! We don’t want our fur babies to become a little too chubby for their own good.

Clicker Training

Clicker training is a form of positive reinforcement that uses a clicker to mark desired behavior and then rewards the pet. This method relies on operant conditioning, where the animal learns through trial and error.


  • Clicker training is highly effective for teaching pets complex tasks and tricks.
  • It allows for precise timing, making it easier to communicate with your pet.
  • This method can be used for various types of animals, not just dogs.


  • Clickers may be confusing or distracting for some pets.
  • Like any training method, it requires consistency and patience from the owner.
  • The need for specific equipment (clicker) may make this method less accessible for some owners.

Dominance-Based Training

Dominance-based training is based on the belief that animals are hierarchical and need to be dominated by their owner in their commands. This method often uses physical corrections or punishment to assert dominance.


  • Proponents of this method claim it can quickly establish obedience and control over the pet.
  • It may work for some breeds with dominant personalities or strong-willed behavior.
  • Some owners feel more in control using this method.


  • Dominance-based training has been criticized for being outdated and potentially harmful to pets.
  • Physical punishment can lead to fear, aggression, and other behavioral issues in pets.
  • No scientific evidence supports the idea that dogs view their owners as pack leaders or dominant figures. While dominance-based training may show short-term results, it can have negative long-term consequences for the pet’s well-being and the owner’s relationship with them. It is essential to consider more positive and humane methods of training.

Crate Training

Crate training involves using a crate or kennel as a safe and confined space for the pet. The goal is to teach the pet to view the crate as a comfortable and relaxing place rather than a punishment.


  • It can aid in potty training and preventing destructive behavior when unsupervised.
  • It can help travel with pets.
  • Some owners find it helpful in managing separation anxiety in their pets.


  • If not done correctly, it can cause distress and anxiety in the pet.
  • Overuse of the crate can lead to isolation and lack of socialization for the pet.
  • It may require time and effort from the owner to properly introduce their pet to the crate.

Ideally, you should only use a crate when necessary and make sure to provide your pet with plenty of exercise and mental stimulation outside of the crate. Crate training should never be used as a punishment or long-term confinement solution.

Leash Training

Leash training involves teaching your pet to walk calmly while on a leash. This is important for the safety of both the pet and the owner and for following local leash laws.


  • It allows for safe and controlled walks with your pet.
  • It can help prevent pulling and lunging behaviors.
  • Some owners find it helpful in establishing their role as leaders.


  • Leash training can be challenging and time-consuming, especially with strong or high-energy breeds.
  • If not done correctly, it can lead to discomfort or injury for the pet.
  • It may require patience and consistency from the owner to see results.




Photo of author


I'm Jethro. I'm a carpenter, and love to build things! You can find me in the garage or at work most days of the week.My sister is Crystal, who you might know from this very blog. Her son Johnny loves video games just as much as I do - so we have a lot of fun playing together!

Leave a Comment