Is it Better to Read a Book or an Ebook? Exploring the Pros and Cons

Ever found yourself in a bookstore, weighing a hardcover in one hand while your phone, full of unread ebooks, sits in your pocket? You’re not alone. It’s the modern reader’s dilemma: the timeless appeal of a physical book versus the incredible convenience of an ebook.

With digital readers like the Amazon Kindle and Barnes & Noble Nook becoming staples, the question of whether it is better to read a book or an ebook is more relevant than ever. This isn’t just about preference; it’s about how we absorb information, the strain on our eyes, and even our impact on the environment.

We’ll explore what recent studies say, from how print can improve comprehension to the surprising data on sales trends. By the end, you’ll have a much clearer picture of what each format truly offers.

The Essence of Reading: Books vs Ebooks

In our hyper-digital world, it’s easy to think of reading as just consuming words. But the format we choose changes the very nature of the experience.

Traditional books offer sensory details that an electronic device can’t match. Think about the smell of old paper, the weight of the book in your hands, or the simple satisfaction of turning a physical page. This isn’t just nostalgia; it’s science.

Research from institutions like Stavanger University in Norway has shown our brains engage differently with physical text. The study found that paper readers reported higher levels of empathy and immersion compared to those reading on an iPad. Print simply boosts comprehension and retention.

On the other side, ebooks represent modern convenience. They save space, offer customizable fonts and brightness, and provide instant access to millions of titles. For avid readers, this is a game-changer.

Both formats have clear advantages. It’s a choice between tactile engagement and technological efficiency. Let’s break down the specific pros and cons of each.

Pros and Cons of Traditional Books

Traditional books offer a unique physicality and reading experience that digital formats can’t replicate, but they also have drawbacks in terms of cost and portability.

Physicality and the Reading Experience

Reading a traditional book is a tactile experience. The feeling of the paper, the smell of the ink, and the physical act of turning a page all contribute to a deeper sense of engagement. An article in Scientific American suggests this physical feedback helps our brains create a mental map of the text, which boosts information recall.

This is backed by numerous studies. A comprehensive 2023 analysis from the University of Valencia, which reviewed studies involving over 450,000 people, found that reading in print can improve comprehension by six to eight times compared to reading on digital devices over the long term.

• Better Retention: The physical layout of a book, with text on left and right pages and the feeling of progress, gives you spatiotemporal markers. Your brain remembers “it was at the top of the left page” which helps lock in the memory.
• Fewer Distractions: A physical book has one job. It doesn’t ping you with notifications or tempt you to open another app, allowing for more focused, deep reading.
• Personal Connection: You can physically interact with the text by dog-earing pages, writing notes in the margins, or underlining passages. This creates a personal artifact of your reading journey.

Cost and Availability

Let’s talk about the bottom line. Brand new hardcover books can be pricey due to printing and distribution costs. However, the world of physical books offers incredible ways to save money if you’re resourceful.

Used bookstores, library sales, and online marketplaces like ThriftBooks are fantastic for finding popular titles at a steep discount. And, of course, there’s the public library, a completely free resource.

On the other hand, ebooks often have a lower upfront cost than new hardcovers. For example, a new bestseller might cost $19 on release, while the ebook version on Amazon Kindle or Apple Books is priced around $15. However, you can’t resell a used ebook, and borrowing from friends isn’t as straightforward.

Impact on Eye Health

A major advantage of physical books is that they are easier on the eyes. Paper doesn’t emit its own light, so you avoid the direct glare and blue light associated with screens. This is crucial for anyone who already spends their day looking at a computer.

When we discuss ebooks, it’s vital to distinguish between two types of screens.

• LCD/OLED Screens: Found on tablets (iPad) and smartphones, these screens are backlit and emit blue light that can disrupt sleep patterns and cause digital eye strain.
• E Ink Screens: Used by dedicated e-readers like the Kindle Paperwhite or Kobo Clara. These screens are not backlit but front-lit, reflecting ambient light just like paper. A study referenced by the Harvard School of Public Health found that E Ink displays are up to three times healthier for your eyes than LCD screens.

So, while any screen can cause some fatigue, the technology in a dedicated e-reader is specifically designed to minimize that strain and mimic the experience of reading on paper.

Pros and Cons of Ebooks

Ebooks offer unparalleled convenience with features like adjustable font sizes and instant downloads. However, the on-screen experience can lead to lower comprehension, and the environmental impact of e-waste is a serious consideration.

Accessibility and Portability

This is where ebooks truly shine. The ability to carry thousands of books on a single, lightweight device is a massive advantage for travelers, commuters, and anyone with limited shelf space.

Ebooks also excel in accessibility. Readers can instantly adjust font size and style, making reading possible for those with visual impairments. Many e-readers also include features like VoiceView on Kindle, a screen reader that can read the text aloud.

Additionally, apps like Libby allow you to borrow ebooks from your local library for free, directly to your device. This combines the cost-saving benefit of a library with the convenience of digital access. Despite these benefits for adults, studies show that children tend to pay more attention and engage better with physical books, making print a preferred choice for early development.

On-screen Reading Experience

The experience of reading on a screen is fundamentally different from paper. Research consistently points to what experts call the “screen inferiority effect,” where people read slower and retain less information from digital texts.

A 2024 meta-analysis confirmed that students who read on paper scored consistently higher on comprehension tests. Why does this happen? Experts suggest a few reasons:

• Tendency to Skim: Our brains are conditioned to scan and skim content on screens, a habit we carry over from browsing the internet and social media.
• Cognitive Overload: The features of a digital device, even just the potential for notifications, can create a low-level distraction that disrupts deep focus.
• Lack of Physical Cues: Without the physical map of a book, it’s harder for our brains to anchor information, leading to shallower processing.

Cost-effectiveness

While individual ebooks are often cheaper than new print books, the total cost of ownership requires factoring in the e-reader itself. A good e-reader like a Kindle Paperwhite or Kobo Libra 2 can cost well over $100.

However, for avid readers, this initial investment can pay off over time. If you read dozens of books a year, the savings per book will eventually cover the cost of the device. Additionally, there’s a vast ecosystem of free or heavily discounted ebooks.

Services like BookBub or Early Bird Books send daily emails with deals on ebooks, often priced at $1.99 or less. This allows voracious readers to build a large library without breaking the bank.

Environmental Impact

The environmental debate between books and ebooks is more complex than it seems. While ebooks don’t use paper, the production of an e-reader has a significant carbon footprint.

Manufacturing an e-reader involves mining rare earth metals, using energy, and contributes to the growing problem of e-waste. A single print book is estimated to generate about 2 kilograms of CO2.

The consensus is that a “break-even point” exists. According to most lifecycle analyses, you need to read between 22 and 30 books on your e-reader to offset its initial environmental impact compared to buying the same number of print books. For an occasional reader, sticking with print (especially used or library books) is the greener choice. For a heavy reader, the e-reader becomes more sustainable over time.

The Shift in Perception: Ebooks vs Traditional Books

When e-readers first launched, many predicted the death of the physical book. That hasn’t happened. Instead, the market has matured, and readers have settled into a more nuanced understanding of where each format fits in their lives.

Early enthusiasm for ebooks has leveled off. A 2021 Pew Research Center survey found that while 30% of Americans had read an ebook in the past year, 65% had read a print book. That figure shows remarkable stability for print over the last decade.

Many readers now practice “format switching.” They might use an e-reader for their daily commute, listen to an audiobook at the gym, and curl up with a paperback on the weekend. The choice is less about which is “better” and more about which is right for the moment.

Interestingly, some data suggests a generational divide, but not the one you’d expect. A 2023 report from Deloitte noted that e-readers are often more popular with older generations who appreciate the portability and adjustable text, while younger readers enjoy collecting and displaying physical books. For them, a full bookshelf is a form of self-expression.

Exploring Sales Statistics: Books vs Ebooks

The numbers tell a clear story: print is not only surviving, it’s thriving. The latest data provides a fascinating look into what people are actually buying.

Print Book Sales

Print continues to dominate the publishing industry. According to the Association of American Publishers (AAP) StatShot Annual report, the U.S. publishing industry generated a robust $32.5 billion in 2024.

Within that total, print formats like hardbacks and paperbacks accounted for the lion’s share of revenue. In 2023, publishers sold 767 million print units in the U.S. alone, showing a sustained demand for physical media.

Ebook Sales

While ebook sales are significant, they represent a smaller portion of the overall market. In 2024, ebook revenue increased by a modest 1.5% to reach $2.1 billion. This indicates a stable but much smaller market compared to print.

Monthly data from the AAP shows these trends continuing into 2025. For example, in September 2024, ebook revenues saw a 4.0% increase compared to the previous year, totaling $90.5 million for the month. This shows steady, but not explosive, growth in the format.

Demographics: Reader vs E-Reader

So, who is using which format? The data provides some surprising insights. While you might assume younger readers are all-digital, that’s not the case. A 2021 survey revealed that 68% of readers aged 18 to 29 prefer print books.

The market for e-readers is highly concentrated. Amazon’s Kindle platform dominates, accounting for about 72% of the e-reader market and 79% of all ebook purchases in the US. This gives Amazon immense influence over the digital reading landscape.

A 2021 Pew Research Center study found that 33% of Americans read both print and digital books, while 32% read only print. Only 9% of Americans are digital-only readers, showing that most people still value the experience of a physical book.

The Future of Reading: Printed Books vs Ebooks

The future of reading isn’t a battle between print and digital, but rather a coexistence where each format serves different needs. Technology continues to evolve, making e-readers more appealing than ever.

Innovations like color E Ink, seen in devices like the Onyx Boox Kaleido 3, are changing the game for graphic novels, magazines, and textbooks. At the same time, the global e-reader market is projected to grow from $8.31 billion in 2025 to over $11 billion by 2030, showing that the demand for dedicated reading devices is still strong.

However, the science remains compelling. As psychologist Kate Garland’s study revealed, our brains simply seem to process and retain information better from physical pages. This fundamental advantage will likely ensure that printed books always have a place.

Ultimately, the choice comes down to personal preference and context. The future is hybrid: a world where you can enjoy the convenience of an ebook on your commute and the deep, focused pleasure of a printed book at home.

Health Implications of Reading Formats

The format you choose for reading can have real effects on your physical and mental well-being, from eye strain to stress levels.

Health Benefits of Reading Traditional Books

Reading physical books is not just about comprehension; it’s a powerful tool for well-being. A well-known 2009 study from the University of Sussex found that reading can reduce stress levels by up to 68%, more effectively than listening to music or taking a walk.

The act of unplugging from a screen and focusing on a single, tangible object helps calm the mind. It improves focus, memory, and critical thinking skills by providing a sensory experience that fully engages the brain. Studies show that print readers often report higher measures of empathy and immersion in a story.

Potential Health Risks of Reading Ebooks

The primary health concern with ebooks is related to screen time, especially from backlit LCD screens on tablets and phones. Extended reading on these devices can lead to digital eye strain, with symptoms like dryness, headaches, and blurred vision.

More importantly, the blue light emitted by these screens can interfere with your body’s production of melatonin, the hormone that regulates sleep. Reading from a tablet or phone before bed can make it harder to fall asleep and reduce sleep quality.

Pro-Tip: If you love reading ebooks at night, use a dedicated e-reader with an E Ink screen. These devices, as discussed in a report from the Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, use front-lit displays that are much gentler on the eyes and emit significantly less blue light, protecting your sleep cycle.

The Role of Audiobooks in the Reading Landscape

No discussion about reading today is complete without mentioning audiobooks. This format has seen explosive growth and is fundamentally changing how people consume books.

The audiobook market is booming. It’s projected to be a $10.88 billion industry in 2025 and is expected to grow at a compound annual growth rate of over 26%. In 2024, digital audio revenue grew by an impressive 22.5%, far outpacing the growth of ebooks.

Why the surge? Audiobooks are the ultimate tool for multitasking. They turn commute time, workouts, and household chores into reading time. This convenience is attracting a huge audience, with major platforms like Audible and subscription services from companies like Spotify making them more accessible than ever.

Audiobooks aren’t replacing other formats but are instead capturing “found time,” allowing people to fit more books into their busy lives. They offer a powerful, immersive experience that complements both print and ebook reading.

Final Verdict: Is it Better to Read a Book or Ebook?

After weighing the evidence, it’s clear there’s no single winner. The best format depends entirely on your goals and circumstances. However, we can draw some firm conclusions.

For comprehension, retention, and a focused, immersive experience, a physical book remains superior. The science consistently shows that our brains are simply better at processing and remembering information from printed pages. For a truly enriching experience that’s easy on the eyes, you can’t beat a good old-fashioned book.

For convenience, portability, and accessibility, ebooks are the undeniable champion. The ability to carry a library in your pocket, adjust font sizes, and access books instantly is a modern marvel. If you’re a frequent traveler or a voracious reader on a budget, an e-reader is an excellent investment.

So, the final verdict is this: don’t choose one. Embrace both. Use ebooks for their portability and convenience, but make time for the focused, deep reading that only a physical book can provide. Your brain will thank you for it.

People Also Ask